
Vanity metrics, defined
A vanity metric is a number that looks good but does not tell you if your marketing is bringing in cases. It goes up, the chart turns green, and nothing changes at the front desk.
Common ones in law firm reports:
- Impressions. How many times your site appeared in search results, whether or not anyone noticed.
- Sessions or visits without any link to calls or forms.
- Keyword counts. "You rank for 400 keywords" says little if few people search them.
- Social reach and likes. Nice to see, but rarely tied to a consult.
None of these are useless. They can point to trends. They just should not be the headline.
Vanity metrics often lead a report because they are easy to grow and easy to show. Impressions can rise just because Google started showing your site for more searches, even ones that will never turn into a call. That is not a bad thing on its own. It just is not proof that anything is working for your firm.
The four numbers that matter
For most small firms, four numbers tell the real story:
- Clicks from search. Real people who chose your site.
- Calls and form fills. People who reached out.
- Consults booked. People who took the next step.
- Cases signed. The number that pays the bills.
A good report shows how these connect from month to month. If clicks rise but calls stay flat, something on the site or at intake needs a look.
You may not see all four in one place at first. That is fine. Start with the ones you can track today, and add the rest over time. Even a rough count of calls and consults each month beats a perfect chart of impressions.
Clicks vs impressions, in plain English
An impression is when your link shows up on a search page. A click is when someone picks it. You can have thousands of impressions and very few clicks if you show up low on the page, or for searches that do not fit.
Clicks are the more honest number, so that is what we report. All Up And Social client numbers we share are Search Console clicks, not impressions. Clicks are not cases, but they are real people who chose to visit.
Average position belongs in the same group. It can be useful to see whether a page is moving up or down, but it is an average across many searches. A page can have a good average and still bring in few clicks if the searches are small or a poor fit. Look at clicks first, then use position to understand why.
Connecting search data to intake
Search tools stop at the website. To know if marketing works, you need to follow the person to the phone.
- Use call tracking or a distinct number for your website, so you can see calls from search.
- Ask every new caller how they found you, and write it down.
- Track forms in a simple sheet: date, source, and whether they booked.
- Each month, compare clicks to calls to consults.
This does not need fancy software. A shared sheet and a habit at intake will tell you more than most dashboards.
Be patient with the first few months. Tracking takes time to settle in, and your team may forget to ask at first. Once it becomes a habit, you will start to see which pages and which sources bring the calls that turn into cases.
What to ask your agency for next month
If your report leads with impressions, ask for a change. Simple questions to send:
- How many search clicks did we get, and from which pages?
- How many calls and forms came from the website?
- Which pages led to those calls?
- What did you change this month, and what is next?
A good agency will welcome these questions. If the answers are vague, that tells you something too.
You can also ask for one thing that did not work. Honest reports include misses, not just wins. That tells you the agency is looking at the real numbers and is willing to adjust.
For more on how to think about spend and results, see our guide to planning your 2027 marketing budget.
Related guides
Up And Social is a marketing agency and does not provide legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

